The Tiger’s Wife by Téa Obreht
Published by Random House, 2011
My rating: ⭐ ⭐
I was left feeling largely apathetic towards this, with almost everything I enjoyed about it being cancelled out by something I didn’t. Obreht’s prose is very nice at times, but the disjointed narrative structure stopped me from getting into the flow of the story. The heavy use of magical realism and allegory allowed for some striking imagery, but kept me at arms’ length with regards to the characters; often lacking enough thematic parallels to feel justified. And whilst there were lots of interesting ideas and plot threads at play, I came away from the book lacking a satisfying sense of closure for most of them. Altogether, I found this overly long and too elusive to feel any kind of emotional attachment, becoming a book I was reading to get through, rather than one I felt compelled to explore or contemplate.
You can pick up a copy of The Tiger’s Wife from Book Depository by clicking here.
Twas the Nightshift Before Christmas by Adam Kay
Published by Picador, 2019
My rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
This follow up to This is Going to Hurt collects more diaries from Kay’s time as a junior doctor, only this time the entries are taken specifically from the seven festive periods he worked. I actually enjoyed this one more than its predecessor. It sets out to make the same core points (that NHS staff are fallible human beings; that their work requires huge amounts of personal sacrifice; that better emotional support systems need to be put in place for doctors; and that the system itself is being criminally underfunded). Being more compact this time, however, these points were unaffected by the blight of diminishing returns.
The ties to the festive period also add extra poignancy; reminding us that life – and indeed death – go on as normal on hospital wards across the country while the rest of us relax, indulge, and celebrate. If there’s ever a time of year we should remember to be grateful to those propping up the NHS from the frontline, it’s Christmastime. Kay’s trademark sarcasm continues to add some much-needed light to the darkness, but in this case, I found the humour less forced – another bonus! This is well worth picking up if you enjoyed This is Going to Hurt, or if you fancy a more condensed version of the same ideas, with a festive twist and an extra dash of resonance.
This would make an ideal stocking stuffer this Christmas! You can pick up a copy from Book Depository by clicking here.
Let’s connect: Twitter | Goodreads | Support me on Ko-fi
Oh, I’m so sorry you didn’t get on with The Tiger’s Wife! It’s funny because, before reading it, I thought it would be all the things you say about it but it totally won me over.
Having looked at some reviews, it seems to be the kind of read that you either really gel with, or struggle to get through. I’m glad to hear you had more success! I can definitely see why so many people liked it.
Great reviews, I would be interested in reading more Adam Kay. I don’t think I’ll be picking up the Tiger’s Wife.
If you enjoyed Kay’s other book, I’m sure you’ll like this one! 😊
Oh god heavy use of m****** r****** I’m so scared of this book and I haven’t even started
I’ll pray for you
I’m laughing but I do feel sorry for you
Great reviews! Your description of The Tiger’s Wife is worded so perfectly, and I completely agree with your points. Though there were striking moments I appreciated in every chapter, as a whole I also found it very disjointed, without sufficient payoff in the end.
I haven’t read either of Kay’s works yet, but they sound very interesting!
Thank you so much! I’m glad it’s not just me that struggled with The Tiger’s Wife, but here’s hoping someone from the group gels with it better than we did!
Oh such a pity about The Tiger’s Wife! I feel like you and I had the best chances of liking this (and Emily perhaps?), but since two of you already disliked it so I’m quite discouraged. But at the moment I’m between 3 and 4 stars.
I hope it wins you round! It does have lots of positive reviews, so perhaps Obreht’s style just didn’t work for me.
Great reviews! I’m glad you enjoyed Adam Kay, I definitely agree about the humour! I’ve heard so many good things about The Tiger’s Wife but have never been fully convinced because of the magical realism 😬
Thank you! Yeah, I often struggle with magical realism too. I find I can gel with it better in short stories, since we don’t have to suspend our disbelief for as long, but here I just found it too jarring, sadly.
Pingback: Review: The Tiger’s Wife, by Téa Obreht | Naty's Bookshelf
Pingback: December Wrap Up | Callum McLaughlin
Pingback: book review: The Tiger’s Wife by Téa Obreht – pace, amore, libri