Queenie by Candice Carty-Williams
Published by Trapeze, 2019
My rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐
Queenie is essentially a coming of age story about the importance of acknowledging the past, and learning to value yourself. In the novel, our 25-year-old titular heroine finds herself sliding increasingly towards rock bottom. Off the back of a messy breakup, she embarks on a string of casual sexual encounters with men who fetishize and manipulate her to the point of abuse. Queenie also feels undervalued in her job at a newspaper, where her requests to cover advancements in the Black Lives Matter movement are constantly rebuked. On top of all that, she feels pressurised to live up to the high standards placed on her by her family, and struggles to deal with events from her childhood that left her relationship with her mother in a poor state.
There’s a good emphasis placed on Queenie’s mental health throughout the book, and this makes her an easy character to root for. Her desire to better herself, and her tendency to use humour to deflect from her own pain are endearing and relatable qualities. This, coupled with the very readable, straight-forward prose, made the novel a breeze to fly through.
I think the success of the book’s attempts to tackle big issues (like institutionalised racism, the long-term impact of suppressed trauma, and the abuse and fetishization of black, female bodies) is partly dependent on the angle from which you look at the novel. When taken as the commercial fiction it is generally marketed as, its social commentary fleshes out the characters at no cost to the novel’s readability – which is great! When analysed from a more literary perspective, however, (which seems unavoidable now it has started cropping up on book prize longlists), it’s trajectory feels too predictable, and its handling of wider themes too simplistic and heavy-handed. Carty-Williams very much adopts the ‘tell’ approach, rather than the more nuanced method of ‘showing’, with her characters spelling out in no uncertain terms every point she ever set out to make with the novel – even when it feels clumsily woke and self-aware.
You can agree with everything an author is saying, and respect the significance of the topics being addressed, but still not want to have everything spoon-fed to you through the narration. That was my only real issue with Queenie; that it left no room for interpretation, and invited no further contemplation or discussion beyond the page.
This is a fine enough book overall; easy to read and hard to complain about, but in no way as bold or subversive as it could have been.
You can pick up a copy of Queenie from Book Depository by clicking here.
WOMEN’S PRIZE 2020 REVIEWS SO FAR:
1. Girl, Woman, Other | 2. Hamnet | 3. Fleishman Is in Trouble | 4. Girl | 5. A Thousand Ships | 6. Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line | 7. Dominicana | 8. The Most Fun We Ever Had | 9. Weather | 10. How We Disappeared | 11. Red at the Bone | 12. Nightingale Point | 13. The Dutch House | 14. Actress
Let’s connect: Twitter | Goodreads | Support me on Ko-fi
I’ve been thinking about picking this up lately since so many people have recently recommended it to me. Thanks for sharing this review!
My pleasure! Hope you enjoy it if you decide to pick it up.
Great review; I’m glad you enjoyed this one! The fact that the commentary is bluntly “told” rather than shown seems to be a common critique of this book, so I’ll look out for that. I actually read Queenie a while ago (as one of my read-on-the-commute books), but I wasn’t reading from a literary perspective at all! Planning to re-read this one in the context of the WP longlist soon.
Thank you! It’ll be really interesting to see how this stands up to a second read, especially when viewed through a more critical, literary eye.
I can’t really figure out where to place this book. On one hand she has been compared to an ethnic Bridget Jones (which is probably highly misleading) and on the other hand – as you mention – the book pops on book prize longlists. I am curious, but not entirely convinced, about this one.
It’s certainly a decent read from a character standpoint, but I can’t say it’s the most compelling or accomplished thing I’ve read on a literary front.
I like how you looked at this from a commercial and literary standpoint, because certainly it’s an important book, but I’m not sure if it’s a literary one. The very heavy-handed commentary put me off as well. Great review!
Thank you! Yes, it’s hard not to view a book from a more critical perspective when you know it’s been listed for literary prizes. It’s certainly a decent read with a likeable main character, but I don’t think it offers anything particularly noteworthy in terms of thematic nuance or writerly craft.
Great review! I appreciate how you look at it from both a commercial and a literary perspective.
Thank you! 😊
Pingback: Wolf Hall Trilogy by Hilary Mantel | Mini Reviews | Callum McLaughlin
Pingback: Reading the Women’s Prize Longlist | Wrap Up, Wish list & Shortlist Predictions | Callum McLaughlin
Good review, will read the book if I had the opportunity.
Thank you! I hope you enjoy it if and when you get around to it.
Excellent review! This is exactly how I felt about this book as well, that it’s easy enough to like and agree with but still a bit frustrating not to be given more room to engage with the themes. Sadly I think its place on a prize longlist (and thus readers turning a more literary eye toward it) isn’t doing this book any favors, though it is great to see it have its moment of commercial popularity.
Thank you! Yes, exactly! I can admire the intention behind listing this one, but sometimes a decent book can actually suffer beneath the extra weight of expectation that comes with a major literary prize.
I have been meaning to read this book, Candice Carty-Williams has quite a lovely and interesting Twitter presence. Sounds as if I should reign in my expectations a little, but it could be the lighter book I’m after at the moment 🙂
It’s definitely a solid read with an endearing protagonist, so there’s lots to enjoy! I think my expectations were simply raised too high by the book’s inclusion on a few prize longlists. I hope you enjoy it!
Pingback: April Wrap Up | Callum McLaughlin